Our Story Menu Why Us Reviews Visit 📞 Call Now
Forestville's Neighborhood Deli

Savor Every Handcrafted Bite at Your Local Deli

From our oven-fresh bread to our house-cured meats, every sandwich at Caves is built with care, loaded with flavor, and made to make your day a little brighter.

See Our Menu Call to Order
Delicious freshly made sandwich at Caves Delicatessen
🥪
50+
Sandwich Varieties
⭐
4.9
Average Rating
★★★★★
Loved by locals
Forestville & beyond
Open Today
Until 7:00 PM
Warm interior of Caves Delicatessen
Fresh bread at Caves Deli
Deli counter with fresh ingredients
Our Story

A Forestville Tradition You Can Taste

Caves Delicatessen has been a cornerstone of the Forestville community for years — a place where neighbors become friends over pastrami on rye and the best corned beef you'll ever have. We source locally, prepare everything from scratch, and treat every order like it's for our own table.

🥩

House-Cured Meats

Our pastrami, corned beef, and ham are cured in-house using time-honored recipes that deliver unmatched flavor.

🌿

Fresh Every Day

Vegetables are chopped daily, bread arrives fresh, and nothing sits on our shelves past its prime.

❤️

Made With Heart

Every sandwich is built by hand with care. No shortcuts, no rush — just honest food made the right way.

Explore Our Menu
Why Caves

What Makes Us Different

It's not just what goes into our sandwiches — it's everything that goes into the experience.

🍞

Baked Fresh Daily

Our bread arrives every morning — warm, crusty, and ready to become the foundation of something great.

🥒

Locally Sourced Produce

We partner with regional farms to bring you the crispest vegetables and the freshest ingredients all year round.

👨‍🍳

Expert Sandwich Artists

Our team knows their craft. Every sandwich is built with precision, balance, and a generous hand.

🏠

Community First

We're not a chain — we're your neighbors. Supporting local events, sourcing local, and serving with a smile.

⚡

Fast Without Rushing

Quick service doesn't mean rushed food. We get you out the door fast without cutting a single corner.

💯

Satisfaction Guaranteed

Not happy with your order? Tell us. We'll make it right — because your trust means everything to us.

Testimonials

What Our Customers Say

Don't take our word for it — hear from the people who make Caves their regular stop.

★★★★★

"I've been coming to Caves for years and it never disappoints. The pastrami sandwich is hands-down the best in the area. Friendly staff, always fresh, and it feels like home every time I walk in."

M
Margaret T.
Forestville
★★★★★

"Stopped in on a whim and left as a regular. The Italian hero is massive and packed with flavor. You can tell they actually care about the quality of what they're serving here."

R
Robert K.
Nearby Town
★★★★★

"This is what a deli should be — honest food, warm people, and zero pretense. My go-to spot for lunch. The corned beef is incredible and the pickles are the perfect finish."

S
Susan L.
Forestville
Visit Us

Find Us on Main Street

We're right in the heart of Forestville — easy to find, impossible to forget.

Address

3 Main St
Forestville, NY 14062-9777

Hours

Monday – Friday 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Call to Place an Order
Ready?

Come Hungry, Leave Happy

Whether it's a quick lunch or a relaxed meal with family, Caves Delicatessen is your spot for honest, hearty food in the heart of Forestville.

Call (171) 696-2931 Get Directions
Is this your business?This is my business